US Open Cup · 23-05-2012

FT

Rochester Rhinos

3 : 0

Brooklyn Italians

US Open Cup · 16-05-2012

FT

Portland Phoenix

2 : 3

Brooklyn Italians

US Open Cup · 15-05-2013

FT

Brooklyn Italians

1 : 4

Icon

US Open Cup · 29-05-2014

FT

NY Cosmos

2 : 0

Brooklyn Italians

US Open Cup · 15-05-2014

FT

Jersey Express

2 : 4

Brooklyn Italians

US Open Cup · 14-05-2015

FT

Long Island Rough Riders

3 : 1

Brooklyn Italians

US Open Cup · 10-05-2018

FT

Brooklyn Italians

0 : 2

Lansdowne Bhoys

US Open Cup · 07-05-2018

FT

Brooklyn Italians

3 : 2

NY Cosmos B