USL League Two · 19-05-2024

FT

Morris Elite

0 : 1

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 23-05-2024

FT

Hudson Valley Hammers

3 : 0

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 25-05-2024

FT

New Jersey Copa

1 : 2

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 30-05-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

1 : 1

Ironbound

USL League Two · 03-06-2024

FT

Manhattan

3 : 0

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 09-06-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

0 : 4

Westchester Flames

USL League Two · 19-06-2024

FT

Ironbound

1 : 3

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 23-06-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

1 : 0

New Jersey Copa

USL League Two · 27-06-2024

FT

Long Island Rough Riders

1 : 1

Staten Island Athletic

USL League Two · 04-07-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

0 : 3

Long Island Rough Riders

USL League Two · 07-07-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

0 : 1

Cedar Stars Rush

USL League Two · 14-07-2024

FT

Staten Island Athletic

0 : 5

FC Motown II

USL League Two · 22-05-2025

FT

Staten Island Athletic

2 : 1

Cedar Stars Rush

USL League Two · 26-05-2025

FT

Staten Island Athletic

1 : 2

Morris Elite

USL League Two · 29-05-2025

FT

Staten Island Athletic

2 : 0

Ironbound